I mentioned in my post earlier today ('All good news in today's employment data') that Australia's jobs statistics have been bouncing around in the same way that ours have, and as it happened Australia's latest numbers came out while I was writing. Same again: this year, the seasonally adjusted estimates of new jobs created each month in Australia have been +12,300 (January), an outsized +71,700 (February), a slump of -31,200 (March), and now a large +50,100 (April). No wonder the economic forecasters have been baffled by trying to pick the monthly numbers - the consensus forecast was for +11,000 jobs, well below what actually happened.
Or did it? The variability in the statistics is, very likely, not mirroring what is actually happening in the economy. The best advice at the moment (as I said in that earlier post) is probably not to pay much mind to the seasonally adjusted numbers (though these will be the ones featured in the media) and look at the 'trend' estimates, which take out a lot of the fluff and noise. On the trend basis, new jobs each month this year were +18,900 (January), +19,700 (February), +18,400 (March), and +16,500 (April).
That looks much more reflective of what has been actually happening - ongoing though modest growth in the Australian economy, with the mining sector slowing down from its previous boom-time investment spending and the rest of the Australian economy not picking up the slack.
Thursday, 9 May 2013
All good news in today's employment data
Everything came up trumps in today's labour market statistics. Seasonally adjusted, employment grew by 12,000 in the March quarter, the employment rate (the share of the workforce in a job) went up a little from 63.3% to 63.5%, the number of hours worked (a good indication of the overall state of activity in the economy) increased by a substantial 3.2%, and the unemployment rate went down, from 6.8% to 6.2%.
While there's nothing wrong with part-time jobs - they suit a lot of employers and employees - it was also good news that full-time jobs have been especially strong. And a new measure of the underemployment rate (those "part-time workers who are available and want to work more hours") was also positive: Statistics NZ doesn't have seasonally adjusted numbers for it, so we can't properly compare March '13 with December '12, but compared with a year ago, the numbers underemployed dropped by 9,800 to 83,300, and the underemployment rate dropped from 4.2% to 3.7%.
And if you're especially concerned about youth unemployment, as you should be, the good news kept on coming. Over the past year, the number of unemployed younger people (15-24) dropped by 10,500, explained by a 11,200 drop in the number of 20-24 year olds unemployed. For them, the unemployment rate dropped sharply, from 15.0% to 10.9%. And the seasonally adjusted 'NEET' rate (those aged 15-24 'not in employment, education, or training', or in other words, at a loose end, voluntarily or involuntarily) also dropped, from 14% in the December quarter (and 13.7% a year ago) to 12.5% in this latest March quarter.
The numbers have been flattered by an especially strong labour market in Canterbury (which is what you'd expect), but this is overall an encouraging set of statistics.
In passing, while everyone is used to paying the most attention to the seasonally adjusted numbers - as you normally would - they continue to show quite a lot of volatility, and are showing what look at first glance like big changes in the labour market from one quarter to the next. For example, the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate rose sharply in the September quarter of last year, from 6.8% to 7.3%, dropped back to square one in December (6.8% again), and dropped sharply again this time round, to 6.2%. It might be genuine, it might be the sort of sampling error that can happen to any statistics, who knows - and, oddly, the Australian monthly jobs numbers are doing the same thing - but currently it's probably better to go by what Stats calls the 'trend' measures rather than the 'seasonally adjusted' ones. These have the advantage of taking out a fair amount of whatever random noise is causing the numbers to jump around: even on a trend basis, however, the same picture emerges of a substantial improvement in the labour market in the March quarter.
Finally, readers might like to know that Stats also includes an international comparison of unemployment rates in these labour market releases. The unemployment rates are 'harmonised', meaning they are workably comparable across countries. How do we stack up against the 34 countries listed?
Reasonably well: our latest unemployment rate (6.2%) is clearly below the OECD average of 8.0%, and we rank equal 11th out of the 34 (an improvement from 14th of 34 in December '12). Top of the heap are Korea (3.3%) and Norway (3.4%), Australia and Germany are doing quite well (5.4%, joint 8th), France (as I've been blogging in recent days) is doing badly (10.8%, ranked 27th), though nowhere near as badly as the 'PIIGS' (Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece, Spain). Greece is worst of all (26.4%), and Spain only marginally better (26.3%).
While there's nothing wrong with part-time jobs - they suit a lot of employers and employees - it was also good news that full-time jobs have been especially strong. And a new measure of the underemployment rate (those "part-time workers who are available and want to work more hours") was also positive: Statistics NZ doesn't have seasonally adjusted numbers for it, so we can't properly compare March '13 with December '12, but compared with a year ago, the numbers underemployed dropped by 9,800 to 83,300, and the underemployment rate dropped from 4.2% to 3.7%.
And if you're especially concerned about youth unemployment, as you should be, the good news kept on coming. Over the past year, the number of unemployed younger people (15-24) dropped by 10,500, explained by a 11,200 drop in the number of 20-24 year olds unemployed. For them, the unemployment rate dropped sharply, from 15.0% to 10.9%. And the seasonally adjusted 'NEET' rate (those aged 15-24 'not in employment, education, or training', or in other words, at a loose end, voluntarily or involuntarily) also dropped, from 14% in the December quarter (and 13.7% a year ago) to 12.5% in this latest March quarter.
The numbers have been flattered by an especially strong labour market in Canterbury (which is what you'd expect), but this is overall an encouraging set of statistics.
In passing, while everyone is used to paying the most attention to the seasonally adjusted numbers - as you normally would - they continue to show quite a lot of volatility, and are showing what look at first glance like big changes in the labour market from one quarter to the next. For example, the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate rose sharply in the September quarter of last year, from 6.8% to 7.3%, dropped back to square one in December (6.8% again), and dropped sharply again this time round, to 6.2%. It might be genuine, it might be the sort of sampling error that can happen to any statistics, who knows - and, oddly, the Australian monthly jobs numbers are doing the same thing - but currently it's probably better to go by what Stats calls the 'trend' measures rather than the 'seasonally adjusted' ones. These have the advantage of taking out a fair amount of whatever random noise is causing the numbers to jump around: even on a trend basis, however, the same picture emerges of a substantial improvement in the labour market in the March quarter.
Finally, readers might like to know that Stats also includes an international comparison of unemployment rates in these labour market releases. The unemployment rates are 'harmonised', meaning they are workably comparable across countries. How do we stack up against the 34 countries listed?
Reasonably well: our latest unemployment rate (6.2%) is clearly below the OECD average of 8.0%, and we rank equal 11th out of the 34 (an improvement from 14th of 34 in December '12). Top of the heap are Korea (3.3%) and Norway (3.4%), Australia and Germany are doing quite well (5.4%, joint 8th), France (as I've been blogging in recent days) is doing badly (10.8%, ranked 27th), though nowhere near as badly as the 'PIIGS' (Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece, Spain). Greece is worst of all (26.4%), and Spain only marginally better (26.3%).
Wednesday, 8 May 2013
Today's interest rate cut in Australia
Our Reserve Bank's job just got a little tougher. On a day when its fiscal stability report indicated that it has serious concerns about the potential systemic impact of lending on frothily priced housing, we hear from the ASB that its latest survey of Housing Confidence showed the highest proportion ever (63%) of respondents expecting house prices to rise, while across the Tasman the RBA has cut its cash rate from 3% to 2.75%.
As noted here earlier (see the graphs in 'The RBNZ's dilemma', April 29), easier monetary policy overseas makes the RBNZ's current problems more difficult: wider interest rate differentials, after monetary policy easings overseas, have made the NZ$ more attractive (aggravating the already overvalued NZ$), and the normal response here (a lower cash rate) is ruled out for fear of further inflating the hot housing market. No wonder our RB has been driven (as we also learned today) to trying forex market intervention to try and drive the Kiwi down by non-interest-rate means.
As noted here earlier (see the graphs in 'The RBNZ's dilemma', April 29), easier monetary policy overseas makes the RBNZ's current problems more difficult: wider interest rate differentials, after monetary policy easings overseas, have made the NZ$ more attractive (aggravating the already overvalued NZ$), and the normal response here (a lower cash rate) is ruled out for fear of further inflating the hot housing market. No wonder our RB has been driven (as we also learned today) to trying forex market intervention to try and drive the Kiwi down by non-interest-rate means.
Eurozone risks - France (2)
I referred in an earlier post to the inability and unwillingness of the current French government to confront the main issues France faces. And there's been a lot of comment, especially after last weekend's anti-Hollande protest demonstrations made them topical, about his government's lack of grip and the President's own consequent poor standing in the polls.
It's certainly true that many current French economic policies are either wrong-headed or inadequate. Examples are Hollande's campaign pledges to hire 60,000 more teachers when the fiscal deficit is already too high, and to wind back the one headline reform his predecessor, Nicolas Sarkozy, had managed to implement (raising the age of eligibility for superannuation to 62).
What's striking in particular is how out of date some of them are. 75% top income tax rates, one of President Hollande's cunning plans, take us all the way back to the counterproductive policies of 50 years ago. Remember when the Beatles wrote 'Mister Taxman'? - "Let me tell you how it will be, There's one for you, nineteen for me...Should five percent appear too small, Be thankful I don't take it all". Is 75% way above any kind of optimal tax rate? Is it likely to produce a flight of the most talented, internationally mobile, and most productive? Is the flight already happening? Will the policy result in a lower rather than a higher tax take? Could all of this have been predicted? Respectively, yes, yes, yes, probably, and yes.
Perhaps it's because France's Socialists rarely command all the levers of power, and when they do eventually get hold of them (as they do today at all national and virtually all regional levels), they take over with the policies in vogue when they last held sway. Whatever the reason, their policies often tend to be decades behind the times. I'm reminded that, just as the Western world was about to embark on a massive privatisation programme, the French government under President Mitterrand moved to nationalise the French banks in 1981 (prompting, by the way, banker Baron Guy de Rothschild's mordant comment, ""A Jew under Pétain, a pariah under Mitterrand. For me, it's enough. To rebuild on ruins twice in a lifetime is too much").
All that said, I wouldn't be entirely sure that Hollande is as inept as the commentariat and the latest polls would make out. Hollande is intellectually smart (an énarque, a graduate of the prestigious Ecole Nationale d'Administration), politically astute (he manoeuvred through the fratricidal currents of the Socialist Party for decades), and electorally lucky: first, the front runner for the Socialist presidential nomination, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, imploded spectacularly, and second, Hollande benefitted from the "anyone but Sarkozy" vote. He didn't have much to spare - he got 51.7% of the final run-off vote - but he knocked off a sitting President, no mean feat.
There are also some recent signs of more rational economic policy - a warmer approach to business, revisions to an ill-judged capital gains tax proposal, some changes to labour laws - and, for me, one good sign in the appointment of Jean Pisani-Ferry, previously the director of the highly regarded Bruegel think-tank, as director of the French Prime Minister's Economic Policy Planning staff. You can get a flavour of what Pisani-Ferry is likely to be advising, as well as a very good analysis of the Eurozone's issues, here.
The policy outlook, in sum, is very much in the balance right now. The Eurozone's second largest economy could be starting to move to more conventional, effective management, or it might drift on in the muddle-headed way of the past year. I'll update with any developments that indicate which path looks the more likely.
It's certainly true that many current French economic policies are either wrong-headed or inadequate. Examples are Hollande's campaign pledges to hire 60,000 more teachers when the fiscal deficit is already too high, and to wind back the one headline reform his predecessor, Nicolas Sarkozy, had managed to implement (raising the age of eligibility for superannuation to 62).
What's striking in particular is how out of date some of them are. 75% top income tax rates, one of President Hollande's cunning plans, take us all the way back to the counterproductive policies of 50 years ago. Remember when the Beatles wrote 'Mister Taxman'? - "Let me tell you how it will be, There's one for you, nineteen for me...Should five percent appear too small, Be thankful I don't take it all". Is 75% way above any kind of optimal tax rate? Is it likely to produce a flight of the most talented, internationally mobile, and most productive? Is the flight already happening? Will the policy result in a lower rather than a higher tax take? Could all of this have been predicted? Respectively, yes, yes, yes, probably, and yes.
Perhaps it's because France's Socialists rarely command all the levers of power, and when they do eventually get hold of them (as they do today at all national and virtually all regional levels), they take over with the policies in vogue when they last held sway. Whatever the reason, their policies often tend to be decades behind the times. I'm reminded that, just as the Western world was about to embark on a massive privatisation programme, the French government under President Mitterrand moved to nationalise the French banks in 1981 (prompting, by the way, banker Baron Guy de Rothschild's mordant comment, ""A Jew under Pétain, a pariah under Mitterrand. For me, it's enough. To rebuild on ruins twice in a lifetime is too much").
All that said, I wouldn't be entirely sure that Hollande is as inept as the commentariat and the latest polls would make out. Hollande is intellectually smart (an énarque, a graduate of the prestigious Ecole Nationale d'Administration), politically astute (he manoeuvred through the fratricidal currents of the Socialist Party for decades), and electorally lucky: first, the front runner for the Socialist presidential nomination, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, imploded spectacularly, and second, Hollande benefitted from the "anyone but Sarkozy" vote. He didn't have much to spare - he got 51.7% of the final run-off vote - but he knocked off a sitting President, no mean feat.
There are also some recent signs of more rational economic policy - a warmer approach to business, revisions to an ill-judged capital gains tax proposal, some changes to labour laws - and, for me, one good sign in the appointment of Jean Pisani-Ferry, previously the director of the highly regarded Bruegel think-tank, as director of the French Prime Minister's Economic Policy Planning staff. You can get a flavour of what Pisani-Ferry is likely to be advising, as well as a very good analysis of the Eurozone's issues, here.
The policy outlook, in sum, is very much in the balance right now. The Eurozone's second largest economy could be starting to move to more conventional, effective management, or it might drift on in the muddle-headed way of the past year. I'll update with any developments that indicate which path looks the more likely.
Saturday, 4 May 2013
The Auckland housing market
Snail mail is dying, as are (genuine) landline phone calls - most of the calls we get at home are the phone equivalent of spam, particularly the one that starts with a recording that says, "This is a VERY important message...". I don't know who keeps calling us with this one, as I've been too irritated to let it play out, and I'd hoped there was something down the back of the Telecommunications Act 2001 that would shut it down. I looked up the Act http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2001/0103/latest/DLM124961.html?src=qs and found what I thought might have addressed it (s112), but it only applies to calls made with "for the purpose of disturbing, annoying, or irritating any person" (my italics), and I suppose their lawyers would argue the purpose was to sell whatever they are peddling. If they can afford lawyers: after alienating so much of their customer base, I doubt they will be rolling in cash.
In any event, about the only genuine calls and letters we have received in recent weeks, apart from intra-family stuff, have been from Auckland real estate agents. They all say the same thing: are we interested in putting our house on the market? And this isn't the normal drum-up-business marketing you get from real estate agents a lot of the time. They're desperate to get listings.
The market, in short, is hot: there isn't a lot of supply (hence the calls and letters), and there's strong demand (ditto).
I've posted before that I think the Reserve Bank's biggest preoccupation right now isn't inflation, or the value of the Kiwi dollar: it's the fevered state of the housing market. And I have to say I have a lot of sympathy for the difficulty of the judgements the Bank has to make: with hindsight, if they fail to squash a housing boom and bust, everyone will say, wasn't it obvious? Were you asleep at the wheel? And I'd say, no, it wasn't obvious, and they weren't asleep. You get strong housing markets for perfectly valid reasons (and as a matter of good economic policy, you shouldn't interfere with them), and you get overspeculative booms. They are very hard to tell apart in real time.
At a personal guess, I'd say there are enough fundamentals at play (strong demand from population movements into Auckland, various constraints on supply) to justify what's happened to date. But it could easily tip over into something malign: as housing markets elsewhere have shown, bubbles get underway first because there are genuine fundamental drivers to get the ball rolling, and second because Musical Chairs starts (yes, yes, I know, I could have said something fancier about extrapolative expectations). I still think we're in the benign phase, but I also have a feeling that the guy with the accordion is already in the taxi.
In any event, about the only genuine calls and letters we have received in recent weeks, apart from intra-family stuff, have been from Auckland real estate agents. They all say the same thing: are we interested in putting our house on the market? And this isn't the normal drum-up-business marketing you get from real estate agents a lot of the time. They're desperate to get listings.
The market, in short, is hot: there isn't a lot of supply (hence the calls and letters), and there's strong demand (ditto).
I've posted before that I think the Reserve Bank's biggest preoccupation right now isn't inflation, or the value of the Kiwi dollar: it's the fevered state of the housing market. And I have to say I have a lot of sympathy for the difficulty of the judgements the Bank has to make: with hindsight, if they fail to squash a housing boom and bust, everyone will say, wasn't it obvious? Were you asleep at the wheel? And I'd say, no, it wasn't obvious, and they weren't asleep. You get strong housing markets for perfectly valid reasons (and as a matter of good economic policy, you shouldn't interfere with them), and you get overspeculative booms. They are very hard to tell apart in real time.
At a personal guess, I'd say there are enough fundamentals at play (strong demand from population movements into Auckland, various constraints on supply) to justify what's happened to date. But it could easily tip over into something malign: as housing markets elsewhere have shown, bubbles get underway first because there are genuine fundamental drivers to get the ball rolling, and second because Musical Chairs starts (yes, yes, I know, I could have said something fancier about extrapolative expectations). I still think we're in the benign phase, but I also have a feeling that the guy with the accordion is already in the taxi.
Friday, 3 May 2013
Eurozone risks - France (1)
There's been a real mix of developments in the Eurozone recently. On the positive side, Italy's finally got a government with some credibility, and Ireland is arguably in the early stages of coming out the other side of a severe austerity programme. On the negative side, the banking crisis in Cyprus materialised largely out of the blue, the rescue plans were very badly mishandled, and there are other banking problems on the horizon (Slovenia, for example). And in the middle we have the ongoing uncertainties about Greece, Portugal, and perhaps Spain. The Eurozone remains capable of generating substantial shocks to global financial markets.
Lurking in the background is perhaps the greatest threat to Eurozone stability and recovery - the structural and cyclical weaknesses of the French economy, and the inability and unwillingness of the current French administration to come to grips with them.
Watch the French 8.00pm news any day of the week - I like TV2's coverage, which is streamed over the Internet, http://www.france2.fr/ - and see the amount, and angle, of coverage given to any proposed redundancies. Job losses are distressing, we all know that, but we also know that employment growth happens because new job creation exceeds old job destruction. The French don't accept that: it's not much of an exaggeration to say that the French world view is that every job has a right to exist in perpetuity, and every incumbent in that job is entitled to stay there.Here's just one illustration of the issues.
The IMF calculates a measure of the true underlying fiscal position, which it calls the 'structural' balance, and is the cyclically-adjusted fiscal balance, further adjusted for any one-offs. France has been systematically worse than Germany as far back as these series go for the two countries (1991). Even if you accept the IMF's projections that both countries will get their houses in order over the next five years - yeah, right - France is starting from a worse position, and will take longer to get back to balance.
One final illustration: youth unemployment. France's rate of youth unemployment (26.5%, on Eurostat's data), is actually worse than the dire Eurozone average (24%). France doesn't break out racial or ethnic unemployment rates - "we are all equally French in the colour-blind eyes of the French State" is the official line, which is partly admirable and partly deeply convenient - but you can guess that, for the Arab and North African kids in the slum-like banlieues, it must be approaching 100%.
Financial markets at the moment have their concerns about France, though real alarm bells are still a long way off: the 10 year French government bond trades at only a modest 50 basis points higher yield than its German equivalent. Even so, there are already people who are of the view that, if there is a big road wreck coming in the Eurozone, it could well happen on the autoroute.
Lurking in the background is perhaps the greatest threat to Eurozone stability and recovery - the structural and cyclical weaknesses of the French economy, and the inability and unwillingness of the current French administration to come to grips with them.
Watch the French 8.00pm news any day of the week - I like TV2's coverage, which is streamed over the Internet, http://www.france2.fr/ - and see the amount, and angle, of coverage given to any proposed redundancies. Job losses are distressing, we all know that, but we also know that employment growth happens because new job creation exceeds old job destruction. The French don't accept that: it's not much of an exaggeration to say that the French world view is that every job has a right to exist in perpetuity, and every incumbent in that job is entitled to stay there.Here's just one illustration of the issues.
![]() |
| Structural fiscal deficit, % of GDP. Source: IMF WEO database |
One final illustration: youth unemployment. France's rate of youth unemployment (26.5%, on Eurostat's data), is actually worse than the dire Eurozone average (24%). France doesn't break out racial or ethnic unemployment rates - "we are all equally French in the colour-blind eyes of the French State" is the official line, which is partly admirable and partly deeply convenient - but you can guess that, for the Arab and North African kids in the slum-like banlieues, it must be approaching 100%.
Financial markets at the moment have their concerns about France, though real alarm bells are still a long way off: the 10 year French government bond trades at only a modest 50 basis points higher yield than its German equivalent. Even so, there are already people who are of the view that, if there is a big road wreck coming in the Eurozone, it could well happen on the autoroute.
The latest move from the ECB
The European Central Bank's 0.25% cut in its main lending rate, to 0.5%, and its restated commitment to open-tap funding of the Eurozone's banks, come as no surprise after the latest statistics from Eurostat. The Eurozone's unemployment rate rose a bit further in March, to 12.1%, while inflation had eased in April, to 1.2%. This left the door widen open for a cut, though apparently (if the report in the May 2 edition of the FT is correct) at least one member wasn't in favour of a cut.
What's more surprising, to me, is how long it's taken for inflation to reflect the depressed state of activity in the Eurozone. As recently as January, inflation was still tracking along at 2% - high for a region running hugely below capacity. It's a reminder of that old 'Eurosclerosis' - the lack of flexibility in the Eurozone's product and labour markets.
What's more surprising, to me, is how long it's taken for inflation to reflect the depressed state of activity in the Eurozone. As recently as January, inflation was still tracking along at 2% - high for a region running hugely below capacity. It's a reminder of that old 'Eurosclerosis' - the lack of flexibility in the Eurozone's product and labour markets.
Wednesday, 1 May 2013
Brand value
I'm fond - my wife would say over-fond, and she's right - of red wine. If I was to face the execution squad in the morning, it would be Cabernet Sauvignon tonight.
The other day, I got a bottle out of what I'm pleased to call my 'cellar', or (in everyday language) the wine racks in the garage. It was Fox Creek's McLaren Vale Cabernet Sauvignon 2004, not a hugely expensive wine to begin with - I got it through the NZ Wine Society, which I recommend - and the label said it would keep for up to five years. I'm not paid in any way for this, and wouldn't like to be, but as recompense for a great wine, here's a link: http://www.foxcreekwines.com.
Nine years from vintage, it was terrific. Even my wife, who's no Cab Sav fan - she'd rather a Shiraz, or a Merlot, or a Pinot Noir, or, let's face it, pretty much anything other than a Cab Sav - loved it. So I e-mailed the makers, and told them what a good wine they had made. And I got a lovely message back, saying they were pleased it had done so well, and that they would fossick around and see if they had any bottles left over of the 2004 vintage, so they could form their own view, too.
Right: the economics of what's going on here.
One: produce a really good product, and there's a chance you get disproportionately rewarded for it. I'll recommend Fox Creek to anyone, and I'll do it wholly on the merits. The real world is often a world of monopolistic competition - the overall wine market is by anyone's definition workably competitive, though no wine is a perfect substitute for any other wine, but each has its individuality - and a small investment in (say) extra quality can pay off big time. Except in France, which supposedly fossilised what is a good wine back in the 19th century. This is a somewhat unsubtle way of signalling that the next few posts are going to be about structural reform in France. Never mind, moving on...
Two: here's a company that listens to its customers. I could go on about being redirected, by many other companies, to a call centre in God knows where, but here, self-evidently, is a company that sees feedback as a value-generating activity rather than as a cost-sucking activity to be minimised.
One of the things I've learned, especially at the BNZ but also at Public Trust, is that consumer feedback - good or bad - is extraordinarily helpful. Occasionally, when a complainant would come through to me personally, I'd tell them, "Look, thanks for letting me know", and they'd be nonplussed. How could I be happy getting my ears ripped off?
But, honestly, I meant it, most of the time. Not always: you get the genuine public, but you also get the deluded, the rip-off artists, and the professionally vexatious (not mutually exclusive categories). But if you're not listening to your customers, how else will you know how your product is travelling in the marketplace? Going back to Microeconomics 101: if 'revealed preference' means anything, and it likely does, then you ought to be sensitive to it. When I lived in Japan, I was struck by the attention Japanese executives paid to market share. To an economist, this was somewhat strange: why wouldn't you give greater attention to things like return on equity? And the answer is, market share tells you, all up, that your combination of price and quality is gaining traction in the marketplace. That's an important thing to achieve, and to monitor. It's not everything, but it's an important something.
Three: this may be more of an MBA thing than an economics thing, but there's clearly also something in the idea of 'under promise, over deliver'. Keep for five years, Fox Creek said on the label, and yet it's terrific at nine - that's really powerful, especially as (I would imagine) it would have a spillover effect on all the other varieties and vintages. It's certainly coloured my view, for the better.
Four: what is brand value, anyway? The accountants have their own ideas about what, and how much, can be put on balance sheets, and they have their own logic for that.. Brand value (wearing economists' goggles, and I don't want any cheap shots about goggles blinding your vision) has to be in some sense the present value of the degree to which you have successfully differentiated yourself (in a monopolistic competition sense) from the pack. I wouldn't want to have to be the guy who had to quantify it, but I can imagine that above-the-pack SPQR (service, price, quality, range) can be measured, and if even it can't, it ought to be what you are aiming for.
And now, two complete digressions.
I don't know who came up with the 'SPQR' tag, but good on them. As you might be aware from previous posts, I like Latin, and SPQR originally stood for 'Senatus Populusque Romanus' (the Senate and the people of Rome). Here's a crossword clue for you: "Sexy classicist" (5,5).
And no matter what my wife might think, the best wine to go with lamb is a Cab Sav. Leave a comment if there are Cab Savs you especially like (or if you misguidedly but sincerely have a different view).
The other day, I got a bottle out of what I'm pleased to call my 'cellar', or (in everyday language) the wine racks in the garage. It was Fox Creek's McLaren Vale Cabernet Sauvignon 2004, not a hugely expensive wine to begin with - I got it through the NZ Wine Society, which I recommend - and the label said it would keep for up to five years. I'm not paid in any way for this, and wouldn't like to be, but as recompense for a great wine, here's a link: http://www.foxcreekwines.com.
Nine years from vintage, it was terrific. Even my wife, who's no Cab Sav fan - she'd rather a Shiraz, or a Merlot, or a Pinot Noir, or, let's face it, pretty much anything other than a Cab Sav - loved it. So I e-mailed the makers, and told them what a good wine they had made. And I got a lovely message back, saying they were pleased it had done so well, and that they would fossick around and see if they had any bottles left over of the 2004 vintage, so they could form their own view, too.
Right: the economics of what's going on here.
One: produce a really good product, and there's a chance you get disproportionately rewarded for it. I'll recommend Fox Creek to anyone, and I'll do it wholly on the merits. The real world is often a world of monopolistic competition - the overall wine market is by anyone's definition workably competitive, though no wine is a perfect substitute for any other wine, but each has its individuality - and a small investment in (say) extra quality can pay off big time. Except in France, which supposedly fossilised what is a good wine back in the 19th century. This is a somewhat unsubtle way of signalling that the next few posts are going to be about structural reform in France. Never mind, moving on...
Two: here's a company that listens to its customers. I could go on about being redirected, by many other companies, to a call centre in God knows where, but here, self-evidently, is a company that sees feedback as a value-generating activity rather than as a cost-sucking activity to be minimised.
One of the things I've learned, especially at the BNZ but also at Public Trust, is that consumer feedback - good or bad - is extraordinarily helpful. Occasionally, when a complainant would come through to me personally, I'd tell them, "Look, thanks for letting me know", and they'd be nonplussed. How could I be happy getting my ears ripped off?
But, honestly, I meant it, most of the time. Not always: you get the genuine public, but you also get the deluded, the rip-off artists, and the professionally vexatious (not mutually exclusive categories). But if you're not listening to your customers, how else will you know how your product is travelling in the marketplace? Going back to Microeconomics 101: if 'revealed preference' means anything, and it likely does, then you ought to be sensitive to it. When I lived in Japan, I was struck by the attention Japanese executives paid to market share. To an economist, this was somewhat strange: why wouldn't you give greater attention to things like return on equity? And the answer is, market share tells you, all up, that your combination of price and quality is gaining traction in the marketplace. That's an important thing to achieve, and to monitor. It's not everything, but it's an important something.
Three: this may be more of an MBA thing than an economics thing, but there's clearly also something in the idea of 'under promise, over deliver'. Keep for five years, Fox Creek said on the label, and yet it's terrific at nine - that's really powerful, especially as (I would imagine) it would have a spillover effect on all the other varieties and vintages. It's certainly coloured my view, for the better.
Four: what is brand value, anyway? The accountants have their own ideas about what, and how much, can be put on balance sheets, and they have their own logic for that.. Brand value (wearing economists' goggles, and I don't want any cheap shots about goggles blinding your vision) has to be in some sense the present value of the degree to which you have successfully differentiated yourself (in a monopolistic competition sense) from the pack. I wouldn't want to have to be the guy who had to quantify it, but I can imagine that above-the-pack SPQR (service, price, quality, range) can be measured, and if even it can't, it ought to be what you are aiming for.
And now, two complete digressions.
I don't know who came up with the 'SPQR' tag, but good on them. As you might be aware from previous posts, I like Latin, and SPQR originally stood for 'Senatus Populusque Romanus' (the Senate and the people of Rome). Here's a crossword clue for you: "Sexy classicist" (5,5).
And no matter what my wife might think, the best wine to go with lamb is a Cab Sav. Leave a comment if there are Cab Savs you especially like (or if you misguidedly but sincerely have a different view).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
